Knife Rights' Day in Court

After five years, Knife Rights finally got its day in court in its Federal Civil Rights lawsuit against New York City and District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. Last Thursday's oral argument wrapped up the actual trial in our long-running battle against New York City's unconstitutional enforcement of the state's gravity knife law against owners of common folding knives.

This was likely the first time a federal judge ever handled a true gravity knife (a German paratrooper knife) in any federal courtroom. That watershed moment came during a demonstration by Knife Rights Chairman Doug Ritter and Plaintiff's attorney Daniel Schmutter of the operation of three true gravity knives and eight common folding knives with bias toward closure. The 11 knives were selected from a total of 15 knives that were brought to court by Knife Rights in compliance with an order from Federal District Court Judge Katherine B. Forrest.

The purpose of the knife demonstrations was to contrast for Judge Forrest the differences in the operating characteristics of true gravity knives compared to common folding knives with a bias toward closure. A true gravity knife, such as that German paratrooper knife, is what legislators had in mind when the statute was passed in the 1950s. True gravity knives open easily by gravity or with minimal centrifugal force the exact same way every time for every person. Common folding knives with bias toward closure cannot open the exact same way every time for every person due to the inherent variability of the bias. Because of this, New York's "wrist flick" test is inherently subjective, variable, inconsistent, and therefore unconstitutionally vague.

The demonstration for Judge Forrest showed her that two individuals had varying degrees of success performing the New York City "wrist flick" test on the exact same common folding knives -- points that are critical to Knife Rights' void for vagueness claim attempting to have the "wrist flick" test declared unconstitutional.

Under current interpretation of New York's gravity knife statute by the courts, all that is required for a person to be found guilty is that a cop or prosecutor can demonstrate to the judge that the knife opens with a "wrist flick," even if the knife's owner cannot do so and even if it takes multiple attempts to succeed in the test. A recent ruling by New York's highest court confirmed that even if the knife's owner had no idea it was even possible to wrist flick the knife open and had never tried to do so, it does not matter.

There is no test that can be performed, or any other means, for any person in New York to be assured that any common folding knife with bias toward closure and a locking blade is not an illegal gravity knife as long as some other person, and in particular some New York cop with more experience, more skill or more strength, can successfully "wrist flick" the knife open.

Whether any of this really matters is now in the hands of New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. Knife Rights' Switchblade and Gravity Knife Law Reform bill that is headed to his desk would put a stop to the unconstitutional wrist flick test by specifically exempting folding knives with a bias toward closure from the definitions in the statute. According to The Village Voice article published two years ago, over 60,000 persons had been prosecuted in NYC over the past decade with the rate doubling in the last five years of that review. We can readily extrapolate that number to be in excess of 80,000 prosecutions today.

If the Governor signs the bill to stop the bogus gravity knife arrests in New York City, then Judge Forrest is unlikely to have to make a decision in the case. If he vetoes the bill, then the Judge will have to issue a decision. Regardless of which way that decision goes, any decision she issues is most likely headed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. This would add years before a potentially binding decision is made, during which the City would likely be free to continue with its persecution of knife owners at a rate of approximately 500-800 prosecutions every month!

We hope that the Governor does the right and just thing and signs this bill into law once it is transmitted to him in the coming weeks. At this point there is no need to call or write the Governor, but we will let you know when we need your help.

Finally, we'd like to again warn those living in or visiting New York City that it has an under 4-inch blade length limit and also requires that any knife be carried COMPLETELY CONCEALED and not visible. The most common cause for a stop and subsequent confiscation or gravity knife arrest is a knife clipped to the pocket, which is illegal in NYC. Using the City's "wrist flick" test, any lockblade knife could potentially be claimed to be an illegal gravity knife.

It isn't over until it's over, and Knife Rights continues to be the one organization getting it done for knife owners in America™. Our tenacity and perseverance exemplified in this case over the past five years, including two previous attempts to remedy the situation via legislation and a successful appeal in the federal lawsuit, is only possible with your generous support. Help Knife Rights continue to forge a Sharper Future for all Americans with a donation in the Ultimate Steel™. You could win your choice from over $170,000 in prizes in the Main Drawing PLUS all who donate between now and July 31st are also eligible for the Tail End Drawing with its own separate pool of over $7,000 in prizes.

Tail End Bonus Drawing
Over $7,000 in Prizes Just for Tail End Donors!

Below see just a few of the Over $7,000 in Tail End Bonus Prizes. Pictured are knives from Andrew Demko, Jerry McClure, Rat Worx, Pro-Tech, White River Knife & Tool and Zac Buchanan. Check out all the new Tail End Bonus Prizes and all the other prizes you could win a



Over $170,000 in Incredible Prizes!

WINNER'S CHOICE - You Choose Your Prize When Drawn!*

Over 100 Prizes Valued to $25,000!

Knife Rights' 2016 Ultimate Steel™ Knives, Guns & More Spectacular is our largest fundraiser ever -- offering you the chance to win incredible prizes including custom knives, firearms, gear, and more - all for a donation as small as $20

We have assembled an astounding array of some of the most unique and valuable prizes anywhere. Your donations support Knife Rights' work defending freedom, so it's a WIN-WIN for everyone when you donate!

It's WINNER'S CHOICE, so when you donate to Knife Rights you are eligible to win your choice of

over $170,000 in knives, guns and more. You don't just get a chance to win; you get a chance to win the prizes you want.

Prizes include a South African Safari, guns and knives from the world's top custom knifemakers and knife companies. Over 100 prizes valued $250 - $25,000! 20 prizes valued at $2,000 or more! 44 prizes valued at $1,000 or more! No prize valued less than $250.

Custom Knife Prizes range from the latest in tactical folders and fixed blades to traditional hunting knives and slipjoint folders, and even swords, from renowned knifemakers including Harvey Dean (with Barry Lee Hands engraving), Johnny Stout, Peter Carey, W.D. Pease, Brian Tighe, Gustavo Cecchini, Edmund Davidson, Gayle Bradley, Ed Caffrey, Barry Dawson and Kirby Lambert, to name but a few of the notable custom knifemakers.

Firearm Prizes include rifles with optional suppressors and pistols from Sig Sauer, Daniel Defense, Beretta, Ruger, DRD Tactical, Smith & Wesson, Glock, Kahr and Gemtech.

See all the prizes at


Both drawings are WINNER'S CHOICE. No less than the first 75 donors drawn will get to choose their prize from all remaining prizes, in the order in which they are drawn. Not only are you helping support Knife Rights, but you could win the exact prize that you want from the over $170,000 in prizes available.

See all the prizes at


Every donation made prior between June 3 and July 31, 2013, the end of this fundraiser, is ALSO eligible for our TAIL END BONUS DRAWING with Over $7,000 worth of knives and other prizes just for those donating in the last month! Winner's Choice in this drawing as well, so you can win what you want!



Donate $100 and receive a FREE Knife Rights 2016 Limited Edition Spyderco Ambitious*, a $60 value without engraving, generously donated by SpydercoPLUS

4 Additional FREE Entries (9 Total)!

Donate $200 and receive FREE a Knife Rights 2016 Limited Edition ESEE Izula* with unique "Shall Not Be Infringed" Laser Engraved Design, an $84 value (without engraving), generously donated by ESEE Knives PLUS 12 Additional FREE Entries (22 Total)!

Donate $500 and receive a FREE Knife Rights 2016 Limited Edition Benchmade 490 Amicus AXIS Assisted Flipper* with Unique Laser Engraved Design, a $250 value (without engraving), generously donated by Benchmade PLUS 65 Additional FREE Entries (90 Total)!

(*while supplies last).

All donors of $60 or more also receive a FREE Knife Rights individual membership or renewal (a $32 value)

Donations can be made online a

or by calling (TOLL FREE) 1-866-889-6268 or 602-476-2702
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM Pacific M-F, Please

Donate to Knife Rights Ultimate Steel™ Knives, Guns & More Spectacular and we all win. Donations support Knife Rights' work as the leading organization protecting and defending your right to own and carry your choice of knives and edged tools. Knife Rights' legislative efforts and lawsuits challenging rogue prosecutors are creating a Sharper Future for all Americans™ and fighting the Second Front in Defense of the Second Amendment™.

See all the prizes at

This offer void where prohibited.*Limitations apply.
Complete eligibility and rules at